The most beautifully crafted, inspiring, exquisitely designed email can help your fundraising skyrocket... unless it lands in a spam folder. Is there anything nonprofits can do to help get those emails into inboxes? Yes, there's a lot you can do to improve your delivery rates and drive open rates. It starts with understanding why emails get routed to spam and knowing the anti-spam rules put in place to protect consumers. And then, there are best practices when crafting and sending your emails that can significantly impact deliverability to email service providers (ESPs).
CharityEngine clients see email deliverability rates north of 99%, so we spend a lot of time understanding how to avoid that spam folder. It's a mix of what you do with the content, actively managing your email list, leveraging reports and technology to adjust sending practices, and always updating both to ensure legit emails get where we need them to go.
Email providers have security measures in place to prevent unwanted messages from landing in their users’ inboxes. CAN-SPAM Act regulations and email service providers (ESPs) individual algorithms can impact your ability to land in your donor's inboxes. But as an email sender, there are things you can, and should do to ensure strong reputation.
Table of Contents
- Best Practices for Email Sending
- Use Double Opt-In: CharityEngine Out of Box Feature
- Maintain a Clean List: CharityEngine Queries
- Maintain a Clean List: CharityEngine Data Enrichment Job
- Authenticate your emails: CharityEngine & External Monitoring
- Monitor Email Frequency
- Avoid Spam Triggers
- Sending by Engagement
- Frequently Monitor Your Deliverability Reports
- FAQs & Additional Materials
- Good delivery practices are the responsibility of the user. Clients are responsible for following CAN-SPAM requirements, monitoring their email sending results and maintaining good email list hygiene practices.
- Email list cleansing (or email validation) is integrated throughout CharityEngine. Fees may apply.Please contact your account manager for pricing questions.
- If you are interested in additional support and consultation, please contact your account manager.
Best Practices for Email Sending
Email deliverability refers to the ability of an email to reach the intended recipient's inbox successfully. Achieving good email deliverability involves following best practices to increase the chances of your emails landing in the inbox rather than getting filtered as spam.
Here are some key best practices:
1. Permission-based list: Only send emails to recipients who have explicitly opted in to receive them. Avoid purchasing email lists or sending to contacts who haven't consented.
2. Use double opt-in: Implement a double opt-in process where subscribers confirm their subscription. This helps ensure that the email addresses in your list are valid and engaged.
3. Quality content: Provide valuable, relevant, and engaging content to your subscribers. Avoid spammy language, misleading subject lines, or overly promotional content.
4. Segment your audience: Divide your email list based on demographics, preferences, behavior, or engagement level. Targeted and personalized emails tend to have better engagement rates.
5. Maintain a clean list: Regularly clean your email list by removing inactive or bouncing email addresses. High bounce rates negatively affect deliverability.
6. Authenticate your emails: Implement SPF (Sender Policy Framework), DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail), and DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance) to authenticate your domain and prevent spoofing and phishing.
7. Optimize for mobile: Ensure your emails are mobile-responsive as a significant portion of users access emails on mobile devices.
8. Monitor email frequency: Avoid overwhelming your subscribers with too many emails. Find a balance in frequency to maintain engagement without causing fatigue.
9. Provide easy opt-out options: Include a visible and easy-to-use unsubscribe link in your emails. Making it difficult for users to unsubscribe can lead to spam complaints.
10. Monitor performance and metrics: Track key metrics like open rates, click-through rates, bounce rates, and spam complaints. Analyze this data to improve your email strategies continually.
11. Avoid spam triggers: Refrain from using excessive exclamation marks, all caps, or trigger words commonly associated with spam in your subject lines and content.
12. Comply with regulations: Adhere to email marketing laws such as the CAN-SPAM Act (in the US) and GDPR (in the EU). Ensure you have the necessary permissions and include a physical address and clear sender identification.
By following these best practices, you can significantly enhance your email deliverability and increase the likelihood of your emails reaching the intended audience's inboxes rather than being filtered as spam.
Use Double Opt-In: CharityEngine Out of Box Feature
How can I activate Email Verification?
Navigate to the Configuration App > Campaigns > Default Settings > Deliverability > Email Delivery Verification = on > UPDATE
Regardless of how the constituent responds, the response means that this is a real person and real people are who the organizations should be sending to.
Constituent who enter the user's CharityEngine account with an email (via web form, data importing, API) will receive a customized email stating "Non-Profit Name" is confirming permission to email you. The constituent will click Yes, I'm ok with receiving emails. Or to Click here if you did not authorize this.
By clicking Yes, I'm ok with receiving emails, the constituent's contact record email address will be marked as Verified
Step 2: Users then leverage the Reputation Mode: Verified Email Only when sending emails from CharityEngine:
Maintain a Clean List: CharityEngine Queries
This may sound simple and obvious, but it makes a difference! Being a good email sender is the number one most important contributor to your domain reputation and IP reputation which, in turn, is the largest contributor to whether your email lands in the inbox or is considered spam. Email providers notice if their users never open emails coming from your domain, so if someone has not opened a message from your organization for a long time, then it is recommended you remove them from your email list (even if they subscribed at one point).
Why does this matter? Because other recipients’ lack of engagement on your messages can tell the email provider that your domain sends unwanted email and they could start sorting your messages as spam rather than desired inbox content, even to recipients who do like to open your mail.
Note: Never purchase email lists. Purchasing of an email list can result in the introduction of SPAM traps and harm your email reputation making it difficult to successfully get your emails into inboxes.
The following instructions can be utilized to create a sending list that considers constituent engagement defined as Viewed Email in last 6 months
- Received Email = True - includes Global Email Opt In
- Primary Email Receive Email = True - includes Primary Emails set as Opt In
- (Primary Email Meta Data Sub Table) Latest View Date = Last 6 Months (use the formula icon to locate filter) - this will limit all email address in which the constituent has viewed an email in 6 months or sooner demonstrating engagement
- (Primary Email Meta Data Sub Table) Is Blacklisted = False - this will eliminate any blacklisted email address
- Where can I monitor and investigate my failed emails? See more at Email Campaign: Investigating Failed Email Delivery
- Have you hit Spam traps? We have a list of providers and actions you can take to remove and correct your reputation Spam Removal: Provider Recommended Actions
Maintain a Clean List: CharityEngine Data Enrichment Job
Email list hygiene is recommended from time to time to make sure you are not emailing bad email addresses. Bad email addresses can range from a common domain misspelling (yaho, gamil, hotmal) (Typo Spam Traps) to known spammy email addresses that end up in lists because of inaccurate data appends or bad list purchases (Pristine Spam Traps). So how can you make sure you are reaching donors who want to hear from you?
- CharityEngine uses an email verification tool on forms (Online Donation Forms, Advocacy Forms, Shopping Cart checkout, etc...) that is used as an opt-in verification, asking your donors if they would want to receive emails from your organization.
Another valuable tool is the email validation process that on a regular cadence, completes list cleansing leveraging a third-party vendors. Fees may apply. This validation of emails will ensure that there are no bad emails in your sending population and will help maintain a good list. If you are interested in learning more, please reach out to your account manager.
CharityEngine Data Enrichment Job (Bulk Job)
Completing an Email Address Validation Data Enrichment Job (fees may apply)
CharityEngine Data Enrichment Job (Select Records)
Completing an Email Address Validation Data Enrichment Job (fees may apply). This use case will allow users to select specific emails for email validation.
Step 7: Validation status will be updated as Valid or Invalid
CharityEngine Data Enrichment Job (Integrated Ongoing)
Users can set automated email address verification via the Configuration App > Campaigns > Campaign Default Settings > Deliverability. Set Email Address Validation = on for automated activation of email cleansing for any new email address.
Authenticate your emails: CharityEngine & External Monitoring
Note: Users who participate in the CharityEngine Shared Pool will benefit from CharityEngine monitoring and set up of SPF (Sender Policy Framework), DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail), and DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance) to authenticate your domain and prevent spoofing and phishing.
For users of a unique sending domain, CharityEngine will support first time set up and verification of SPF, DKIM, DMARC. Users will be responsible for management and monitoring.
Users can monitor internal checks/status by navigating to the Campaigns App > Popular Reports > Email Deliverability
Scroll to the bottom of the report to view the Configuration Analysis section
Monitor Email Frequency
Managing a balance of email sending is important to avoid email fatigue - which can result in constituents opting out and/or reporting emails as Spam. These actions can damage reputation of ESPs.
A Feedback Loop (FBL) (or Complaint) is an essential tool provided by internet service providers (ISPs) and email service providers (ESPs) to help maintain good email deliverability. It allows senders to receive notifications when recipients mark their emails as spam or junk.
Here's how a Feedback Loop typically works:
1. Recipient Marks Email as Spam: When an email recipient considers an email as spam or junk, they have the option to mark it as such within their email client (like Outlook, Yahoo, etc.).
2. ISP/ESP Notification: The ISP or ESP then sends a notification, known as a feedback loop, to the sender of the email whose message was marked as spam. This notification typically include details such as the recipient's email address, the timestamp, and sometimes the reason for the complaint. In some cases, such as Gmail, these ESPs will not provide these details creating a requirement for the user to review and assess.
3. Sender's Action: Upon receiving this feedback, the sender can take necessary actions, such as removing the recipient from the mailing list, analyzing the content for potential issues, ensuring proper opt-out mechanisms, or improving email engagement strategies. In this use case, CharityEngine will automatically assign the email address as Blacklisted to prevent future email delivery.
Feedback Loops are beneficial for several reasons:
- Maintaining Sender Reputation: Monitoring FBL reports allows senders to promptly address issues that might negatively impact their sender reputation, such as high spam complaint rates.
- Improving Email Content: By analyzing the reasons behind spam complaints, senders can identify problematic content, subject lines, or frequency issues and adjust their email marketing strategies accordingly.
- List Hygiene: FBLs assist in maintaining a clean email list by promptly removing recipients who mark emails as spam, reducing the likelihood of future complaints.
Different ISPs and ESPs might have varying processes for setting up and accessing Feedback Loops. Typically, senders need to register and authenticate their email sending domains to receive FBL notifications. For users of CharityEngine's shared pool, CharityEngine will automatically set up for integration to the client's account. For user of a unique sending domain, CharityEngine will assist in the first time set up of the Feedback Loop. Users will be responsible for maintenance and monitoring.
Utilizing Feedback Loops effectively as part of your email marketing strategy can help improve deliverability, reduce the chances of your emails being marked as spam, and enhance overall engagement with your audience.
Users can access and monitor these Complaints from the Feedback Loop by accessing the Campaigns App > Popular Reports > Email Deliverability report.
- Navigate to the Complaints section to see complaint rates, provider specific complaints, and prioritized list of emails which generated complaints for the assigned time frame.
- Note: Industry best practices should be 0.01% or less. Continued reports of complaints by constituents can result in email deliverability issues including delivery of emails to Spam or promotional inboxes - or may result in complete blockage of sending to one or more ESPs.
- User can see specific email reports by user. Access the Reports & Analytics App > Campaigns > Spam Complaints
Monitoring unsubscribes from your email list is a crucial aspect of managing email marketing campaigns. It involves tracking and analyzing the number of subscribers who opt-out or unsubscribe from receiving further emails from your mailing list.
- Use the CharityEngine reporting features to track opt-outs over time. Navigate to the Reports & Analytics App > Campaigns > Email List Health (pivot). From this view users to can visually review trends and rates of email opt out by constituents.
- To see constituent detail, select the Reports & Analytics App > Campaigns > List Unsubscribes
Avoid Spam Triggers
Avoiding spam triggers is crucial to improving email deliverability and ensuring that your emails reach recipients' inboxes instead of being flagged as spam. Here are some best practices to help you steer clear of common spam triggers:
1. Avoid Spammy Content:
- Refrain from using excessive exclamation marks!!! or all CAPS in your subject lines or email body.
- Avoid using words and phrases commonly associated with spam, such as "free," "guarantee," "limited time," "act now," etc.
- Minimize the use of aggressive sales language or overly promotional content.
2. Authenticate Your Emails:
- Implement SPF (Sender Policy Framework), DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail), and DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance) to authenticate your domain. Authentication helps verify your identity and prevents spoofing, which can trigger spam filters.
3. Optimize HTML and Plain Text Versions:
- Ensure your HTML emails are well-structured and not overly code-heavy. Provide both HTML and plain text versions of your emails to accommodate recipients' preferences and avoid triggering spam filters due to poor HTML coding.
4. Carefully Manage Images and Links:
- Avoid using too many images without accompanying text. Some spam filters may flag emails with a high image-to-text ratio.
- Be cautious with link usage; don't use URL shorteners or include too many links in your emails.
5. Regularly Update Your Subscriber List:
- Keep your subscriber list up-to-date by removing inactive or bouncing email addresses. High bounce rates can negatively impact your sender reputation.
6. Personalize Your Emails:
- Personalize your emails by addressing recipients by name when possible. Personalized and targeted emails tend to perform better and are less likely to be marked as spam.
7. Provide Clear Unsubscribe Options:
- Ensure that your emails include a visible and easy-to-use unsubscribe link. Making it difficult to unsubscribe can lead to recipients marking your emails as spam instead.
8. Avoid Misleading Subject Lines or Content:
- Ensure your subject lines accurately represent the content of your emails. Misleading subject lines can result in higher spam complaints.
9. Monitor and Test Your Emails:
- Regularly test your emails using spam-checking tools provided by your ESP or third-party services. Monitor deliverability metrics and adjust your strategy based on the results.
By following these practices and staying updated on email industry guidelines and best practices, you can minimize the chances of triggering spam filters and improve the deliverability of your emails.
Sending by Engagement
Quality email lists are critical for successful inbox delivery. ESP's algorithms will evaluate how their users respond to your emails. Do their users mark your emails as Spam? Do their users look at your emails or simply delete? Are you sending to invalid or inactive email addresses of the ESP? These actions (or inactions) by your donors can trigger an ESP to begin moving your emails to Spam or Promotional inboxes - or in extreme cases, potentially block your emails all together. Consider behavior of constituents to remove sending practices for individuals who have not viewed/opened your emails in 6 or more months. Also, periodically prune your contact list, check for spelling mistakes, typos and remove constituents who either do not engage or have requested to unsubscribe.
Frequently Monitor Your Deliverability Reports
Frequent monitoring and tracking of your email campaigns is an essential part of email sending best practices. Monitoring for delivery rates, complaint rates (i.e. users who reported your email as Spam directly within the ESP), email failures and bounce rates, and deferrals (ESPs who are throttling email delivery to inboxes).
- By accessing the Reports & Analytics App > Campaigns > Email Deliverability
- Alternatively, access the Campaigns App> Popular Reports > Email Deliverability
- Review Delivery Rate trends to identify performance. Use the Failures and Bounce summary to see reason for failed delivery.
- Monitor Complaints (i.e. users who reported your email as Spam directly via the ESP). Industry best practice is to maintain rates below 0.01%.
- Deferrals will demonstrate ESPs that may be deferring or stalling delivery of your email over the course of hours/days.
- Finally, from this report, monitor the health of your SPF/DKIM/DMARC (if on a custom sending domain) and also check for configuration of email address verification and/or email validation.
While the Email Deliverability Dashboard provides an overview, once the organization has identified trends or potential negative actions/results, your organization will now need to take action. Access deeper analytics and performance by reviewing email initiative reporting. Navigate to the Campaigns App > Create & Publish > Initiatives. Review sent initiatives to investigate delivery performance. Hover over reporting elements for summary views and/or the ability to click through for transactional/detail reporting.
The Email List Health (located in the Reports & Analytics App > Campaigns > Email List Health) will allow users to monitor trends and performance in deliverability and response activities of the audience members. Monitoring Opt Out and, Suppression Counts, and Spam Complaints are important aspects to ensure deliverability reputation is maintained as a mass email sending. Positive growth and improved results ensure strong success in delivering to in-boxes vs. delivery to spam or promotional boxes of the email service providers.
Use CharityEngine's robust campaign analytics to review the results and response rates of each of your sends. You are able to monitor any positive or negative results and adjust your tactics quickly. It is also recommended to use third-party inbox monitoring services if you are a medium or high-volume sender. The key benefit of using an inbox monitoring service is that to provide you with insights into how many of your emails are landing in the inbox for larger email service providers like Gmail and Yahoo. It will also provide anonymized statistics about occurrences of complaints and spam traps, which may indicate that you have a list hygiene issue.
While CharityEngine does not provide these services directly, our Client Services team has extensive experience sending email effectively and can recommend some good providers that we and our customers' have had positive results with.
- Where can I monitor and investigate my failed emails? See more at Email Campaign: Investigating Failed Email Delivery
FAQs & Additional Materials
Q. How do I initiate an email to contact those who have not yet verified with our organization?
A. CharityEngine makes it easy to send emails to contacts that have not verified their emails. First you will have to create your list by creating a query that identifies anyone who has not verified their emails. Navigate to the Automation & Workflow App > General > Queries > Create New
Select database Type: Contacts and table Select:Email Address
Add Contact Id, Email Address Id, and Verified to your SELECT fields. Then add Verified to the FILTER section with setting Equals False. This will provide a list of contacts with emails that are not yet verified. Click SAVE to secure your query.
After the query has been created, create an email to send to this contact list. Navigate to the Campaigns App > Create & Publish > Creative > Create New > craft your message.
CharityEngine does have an out of the box token that can be added to your email that will lead the contact to verify their email. In the creative tool bar, click on the Merge Tokens icon to find the Contact.Email Address.Verification URL token.
In the search box, type in Verification, then click on the token. Once clicked, click Copy Selected.
Paste the token into the email creative. This will populate the url for the individual when sent to the identified list.
Click SAVE to secure change and initiate an email blast as normal. Select the audience source as the query name developed above.
Q. How do I review and address emails that have been blacklisted?
A. While CharityEngine strongly recommends following the blacklisting status when applied to an email, learn more here Email Campaign: Email Blacklist Management
Q. Why did this email address fail to send?
A. CharityEngine offers integrated reporting which allows organizations to investigate and take action on failed emails. Learn more here Email Campaign: Investigating Failed Email Delivery